| Home | Energy Physics | Nuclear Power | Electricity | Climate Change | Lighting Control | Contacts | Links |
|---|
INTRODUCTION:
This web page develops a function Z(R) which specifies the position of the spheromak wall. A spheromak's wall geometry can be identified by its nominal linear dimension parameter Ro and by its shape parameter:
Kr = (Rs / Rc)
This web page develops expresions for the spheromak wall parameters: poloidal turn length Lp, toroidal turn length Lt, minimum inside diameter Rc, Maximum outside diametrer Rs, surface charge density:
S = So (Ro / R),
and surface area A.
A numerical method is outlined for finding the spheromak height: 2 Ho.
SPHEROMAK ISSUES:
In a spheromak the electric field inside the spheromak wall is zero.
Spheromak theory indicates that the spheromak charge Q is uniformly distributed along the length Lh of the
charge filament.
spheromak theory further indicates that on the spheromakk wall the surface charge density takes the form:
S(R) = So (Ro / R)^2
Where So is the surface charge density at R = Ro
Assume Z(R) is a symetrical quasi-toroid where the detailed shape is unknown./P> The function Z(R) must comply with all of the following requirements.
A cross section of the spheromak wall can be described by a function:
Z(R) where Z is in the range:
- Ho < Z < Ho
DEFINITIONS:
R = radius from the Z axis (axis of cylindrical symmetry);
Ro = value of R at (dZ / dR) = 0
Rs = maximum value o fR;
Rc = minimum value of R;
Ho = maximum value of |Z|;
Ka = [2 Ho / (Rs - Rc)];
Kb = [(Rs - Rc) / 2 Ro];
SPHEROMAK SYMMETRY:
Due to spheromak symmetry, in the range:
Rc < R < Rs:
Z(R) = - Z(R)
Z(Ro) = Ho, - Ho
Z (Rc) = 0
Z(Rs) = 0
Alternatively:
R(z) has two positive real solutions.
R(z) = R (-Z).
R(Ho) = R(-Ho) = Ro
At Z = 0:
R(Z) = Rc, Rs
SPHEROMAK SCALING:
There is a scaling requirement that:
Ka = 2 Ho / (Rs - Rc)
and
Kb = [(Rs - Rc) / 2 Ro ]
and
Kr = (Rs / Rc)
where Ro = value of R at which (dZ / dR) = 0
We anticipate showing that Ka Kb is a function of physical constants.
SPHEROMAK SHAPE:
(dZ /dR) = 0 at R = Ro, -Ro.
|(dZ / dR)| goes to +/- infinity at R = Rc, Z = 0 and at R = Rs, Z = 0.
SPHEROMAK Lt VALUE:
Lt = Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
2 dLt
or
Lt = Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
2 [(dZ)^2 + (dR)^2]^0.5
or
Lt = Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
2 [(dZ / dR)^2 + 1]^0.5 dR
SPHEROMAK SURFACE AREA:
A = Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
2 Pi R 2 dLt
or
A = Lp Lt Ca =Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
4 Pi R [(dZ / dR)^2 + 1]^0.5 dR
The spheromak surface area is:
A = Lp Lt Ca
Where:
Lp = 2 Pi Ro
Lt = one toroidal turn length
Lp and Lt each scale with Ro.
Ca = shape dependent constant ~ 1
Ro = value of R where (dZ / dR) = 0.
SPHEROMAK SURFACE CHARGE:
S(R) = So (Ro / R)^2
where:
So = charge / unit area on the spheromak wall at R = Ro
SPHEROMAK CHARGE:
Q = Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
2 S(R) dA
or
Q = Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
So (Ro / R)^2 4 Pi R [(dZ / dR)^2 + 1]^0.5 dR
or
Q = Integral from R =Rc to R = Rs of:
So (Ro^2 / R) 4 Pi [(dZ / dR)^2 + 1]^0.5 dR
where:
So = charge / unit area at R = Ro, Z = Ho,and at Z = - Ho, R = Ro
and
S(R) = So (Ro^2 / R^2)
FIND So:
Rearrange above expression to get:
So = Q / {Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
(Ro^2 / R) 4 Pi [(dZ / dR)^2 + 1]^0.5 dR}
SPHEROMAK CONSTRAINT:
There is a further constraint that the spheromak charge Q must be independent of Ro.
The importance of So is that it allows determination of S at R = Rs, Z = 0. At this point the electric and magnetic fields can be matched, potentially allowing determination of Nt, Then knowldege of (Np / Nt) allows determination of Np. These should point toward the Plnnck Constant.
An important isssue is What is the value of Ca?
Recall that:
Lp = 2 Pi Ro Ca
Recall that:
Lp = 2 Pi Ro Ca
Hence:
Lt = A / Lp
= A / 2 Pi Ro Ca
= Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
[4 Pi R / 2 Pi Ro][(dZ / dR)^2 + 1]^0.5 dR
= Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
[2 R / Ro][(dZ / dR)^2 + 1]^0.5 dR
SOLUTION REQUIREMENTS:
1) Lp = 2 Pi Ro Ca
where:
Ro = value of R where:
(dZ / dR) = 0
2) Lt = 2 Integral from R= Rc to R = Rs of:
dLt
= Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
2 [(dZ / dR)^2 + 1]^0.5 dR
where:
Lt must be proportional to Ro.
3) THE TOTAL AREA A OF THE SPHEROMAK WALL MUST BE PROPORTIONAL TO Ro^2.
A = Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
4 Pi R [(dZ / dR)^2 + 1]^0.5 dR
4) Q must be independent of Ro, where:
Q = Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
4 Pi R [So / R^2] [(dZ / dR)^2 + 1]^0.5 dR
5) The aforementioned integrals must converge.
6)(dZ / dR) = 0 at R = Ro.
SPHEROMAK SOLUTION:
Invoke Achem's Razor that the simplest function that meets all the constraint conditions is likely the right one. The required function must produce to quasi-toroid shape and must meet the spheromak performance conditions on Lt, A, and Q.
Attempt solution:
[dZ / dR]^2 = {[(Kc^2 R^2) / (Rs - R) (R - Rc)] - 1}
This function has hidden complexity.
Region of validity is:
Rc <= R <= Rs
and
Kc^2 R^2 => (Rs - R)(R - Rc)
Note that (dZ / dR) changes sign at R = Ro at which point (dZ / dR) = 0.
For Z > 0 and Rc < R < Ro choose (dZ / dR) > 0
For Z > 0 and Ro < R < Rs choose (dZ / dR) < 0
For Z < 0 and Rc < R < Ro choose (dZ / dR) < 0
For Z < 0 and Ro < R < Rs choose (dZ / dR) > 0
Conclusion:
Integration of(dZ / dR) to find the function Z(R) can only be done via a sequence of line integrals, Where thesignof(dZ / dR) is dependent on the sign of Z and the sign of (R - Ro).
Each of the integrations required to find Lt, A and Q must take intoaccount this (dZ / dR) sign change.
FIND Ro:
(dZ / dR) = 0 at R = Ro implies that:
Kc^2 Ro^2 = (Rs - Ro)(Ro - Rc)
or
Kc^2 = ((Rs / Ro) - 1)(1 - (Rc / Ro))
Hence:
Recall that:
[dZ / dR]^2 = {[(Kc^2 R^2) / (Rs - R) (R - Rc)] - 1}
= {[(((Rs / Ro) - 1)(1 - (Rc / Ro)) R^2) / (Rs - R) (R - Rc)] - 1}
Thus:
[dZ / dR] = +/- {[(((Rs / Ro) - 1)(1 - (Rc / Ro)) R^2) / (Rs - R) (R - Rc)] - 1}^0.5
Now express Ro in terms of Kc:
At R = Ro:
[dZ / dR]^2 = 0
which implies that:
{(Kc^2 Ro^2) / (Rs - Ro) (Ro - Rc)]} = 1
or
Kc^2 = [(Rs / Ro) - 1)(1 - (Rc / Ro)]
Alternatively:
Kc^2 Ro^2 = - Ro^2 + Ro (Rs + Rc) - Rs Rc
or
Ro^2 (1 + Kc^2) - (Rs + Rc) Ro + Rs Rc = 0
or
Ro = {(Rs + Rc) +/- [(Rs + Rc)^2 - 4 (1 + Kc^2) Rs Rc]^0.5} / 2 (1 + Kc^2)
= {(Rs + Rc) +/- [(Rs - Rc)^2 - (4 Kc^2 Rs Rc)]^0.5} / 2 (1 + Kc^2)
This equation indicates that Ro has two distinct real solutions, possibly indicating for a positive charge particle that one solution corresponds to a proton and one solution corresponds to a positron. Alternatively for a negative charged particle one solution corresponds to an anti- proton and one solution correponds to an electron.
For real solutions Kc^2 can take values in the range:
0 < Kc^2 < (Rs - Rc)^2 / 4 Rs Rc
When Kc takes its maximum value of:
(Rs - Rc)^2 / 4 Rs Rc
then
Ro = (Rs + Rc) / 2 (1 + Kc^2)
= [(Rs + Rc) 4 Rs Rc] / [2 (4 Rs Rc + (Rs - Rc)^2]
= [(Rs + Rc) 4 Rs Rc] / [2 (Rs + Rc)^2]
= 2 Rs Rc / (Rs + Rc)
Spheromak scaling implies that:
Rs / Rc = Kr= constant.
Then in general:
Ro = {(Rs + Rc) +/- [(Rs - Rc)^2 - (4 Kc^2 Rs Rc)]^0.5} / 2 (1 + Kc^2)
= {(Kr + 1) Rc +/- [ (Kr - 1)^2 Rc^2 -(4 Kc^2 Kr Rc^2]^0.5 / 2 (1 + Kc^2)
= Rc {(Kr + 1) +/- [ (Kr - 1)^2 - (4 Kc^2 Kr)]^0.5 / 2 (1 + Kc^2)
Then when Kc^2 takes its maximum value:
Ro = 2 Rs Rc / (Rs + Rc)
= 2 Kr Rc / (Kr + 1)
or
[Ro / Rc] =2 Kr / (Kr + 1)
or
[Ro / Rc}^2 = 4 Kr^2 / (Kr + 1)^2
On the web page title:
spheromak Approximation we find that the operating value of [Ro / Rc]^2 is given by:
[Ro / Rc]^2 = 2 Kr^2 / (2 Kr + 1)
Note that when Kc = 0 The Ro values are Ro = Rc and Ro = Rs
Recall that:
[dZ / dR]^2 = {[(Kc^2 R^2) / (Rs - R) (R - Rc)] - 1}
Note that (dZ / dR) changes sign at R = Ro where:
(dZ / dR) = 0
The range of validity is: Rc <= R <= Rs
Z(Rs)= Z|R = Rc + Integral from R = Rc to R = Ro of:
(dZ / dR) dR
+ Integral from R = Ro to R = Rs of:
(dZ / dR) dR
where Z(Rc) = Z(Rs) = 0
and the sign of (dZ / dR) switches at R = Ro
FIND So:
Q = Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
4 Pi [So Ro^2 / R][(dZ / dR)^2 + 1]^0.5 dR
or
Q = Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
4 Pi [So Ro^2 / R] [{[(Kc^2 R^2) / (Rs - R) (R - Rc)] - 1} + 1]^0.5 dR
or
Q = Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
4 Pi [So Ro^2 / R] [[(Kc R) / [(Rs - R) (R - Rc)]^0.5 dR
or
Q = Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
4 Pi [So Ro^2 Kc] / [(Rs - R) (R - Rc)]^0.5 dR
or
Q = Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
[4 Pi So Ro^2 Kc] {dR / [-R^2 + R (Rs + Rc) - (Rs Rc)]^0.5}
Let X = R / Ro
Xc = Rc/Ro
Xs = Rs / Ro
Hence:
Q = Integral from X = Xc to X = Xs of:
[4 Pi So Ro^2 Kc] {dX / [-X^2 + X (Xs + Xc) - (Xs Xc)]^0.5}
b^2 = (Xs + Xc)^2 = Xs^2 + 2 Xs Xc + Xc^^2
4 a c = 4 (-1)(- Xs Xc) = 4 Xs Xc
Generally b^2 > 4 a c
Dwight #380.001 gives:
Integral from Xc to Xs of:
dx / [(Xs - X) (X - Xc)]^0.5
for Xc < X < Xs
= [-1 / (- a)^0.5][arc sin{(2 a X + b) / (b^2 - 4 a c)^0.5} evaluated from Xc to Xs
= -1 arc sin{(-2 X + Xs + Xc) / ((Xs + Xc)^2 - 4 Xs Xc) )^0.5 evaluated from Xc to Xs
=-1 arc sin{(-2 Xs + Xs + Xc) / ((Xs + Xc)^2 - 4 Xs Xc) )^0.5}
+ 1 arc sin{(-2 Xc + Xs + Xc) / ((Xs + Xc)^2 - 4 Xs Xc) )^0.5}
= - 1 arc sin{( -Xs + Xc) / (Xs - Xc)^2)^0.5}
+ 1 arc sin{(+ Xs - Xc) / ((Xs - Xc)^2}^0.5}
= - arc sin(-1) + arc sin(1)
= -(- Pi / 2) + (Pi / 2)
=Pi
Thus we have the important intermediate result that:
Integral from Xc to Xs of:
dx / [(Xs - X) (X - Xc)]^0.5
for Xc < X < Xs
= Pi
Hence:
Q = [4 Pi So Ro^2 Kc] Pi
This formula suggests that:
Kc = (1 / Pi).**************************
Rearranging gives:
So = Q / (4 Pi^2 Ro^2 Kc)
Application of this formula to a spherical surface element indicates that:
Kc = (1 / Pi)
.
This formula is used to enable field energy density matching at R = Rs, Z = 0.
FIND Lt:
Recall that:
Lt = Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
2 [(dZ / dR)^2 + 1]^0.5 dR
or
Lt = Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
2 [(Kc^2 R^2) / [(Rs - R) (R - Rc)]]^0.5 dR
or
Lt = Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
2 [(Kc R) / [(Rs - R) (R - Rc)]^0.5 dR
Xc = Rc / Ro
X = R / Ro
Xs = Rs / Ro
dX = dR / Ro
Lt = Integral from Xc to Xs of:
2 Kc Ro [X / [(Xs - X)(X - Xc)]^0.5 dX
Recall that we have the important interim result that:
Integral from Xc to Xs of:
dx / [(Xs - X) (X - Xc)]^0.5
for Xc < X < Xs
= Pi
From Dwight #380.011BR> Lt = 2 Kc Ro {[(a X^2 + b X + c)^0.5 / a]} evaluated from Xc to Xs
- 2 Kc Ro (b / 2a)Integral from Xc to Xs of:
Lt = 2 Kc Ro { [(a Xs^2 + b Xs + c)^0.5 / a] evaluated from Xc to Xs
- (b / 2 a) Pi }
or
Lt = [2 Kc Ro][-b / 2 a][Pi]
= 2 Kc Ro (Xs + Xc) [(Pi / 2)]
or
Lt = Kc (Rs + Rc) Pi
= Kc (Kr + 1) Rc Pi
Note that Rs and Rc scale with Ro so that Lt scales with Ro.
FIND AREA A BY INTEGRATION:
A =Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
4 Pi R [(dZ / dR)^2 + 1]^0.5 dR
= Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
4 Pi R [{[(Kc^2 R^2) / (Rs - R) (R - Rc)] - 1} + 1]^0.5 dR
= Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
4 Pi Kc {R^2 dR / [[Rs - R) (R - Rc)]^0.5}
= Integral from R = Rc to R = Rs of:
4 Pi Kc Ro^2 {(R^2 dR / Ro^2 [Rs - R) (R - Rc)]^0.5}
= Integral from X = Xc to X = Xs of:
4 Pi Kc Ro^2 {(X^2 dX /[Xs - X) (X - Xc)]^0.5}
X = R / Ro
dX = dR / Ro
a = -1
b = (Xc + Xs)
c = - Xs Xc
Recall that we have the important interim result that:
Integral from Xc to Xs of:
dx / [(Xs - X) (X - Xc)]^0.5
for Xc < X < Xs
= Pi
From Dwight #380.021:
A = 4 Pi Kc Ro^2 {(3 b^2 - 4 a c) / 8 a^2} Pi
= 4 Pi Kc Ro^2 {[3 (Xc + Xs)^2 - 4 Xs Xc] / 8 } Pi
= 4 Pi Kc Ro^2 {(2 (Xc + Xs)^2 + (Xs - Xc)^2) / 8} Pi
= Pi^2 Kc {(2 (Rc + Rs)^2 + (Rs - Rc)^2) / 2}
= Pi^2 Kc {2 [(Kr + 1) Rc]^2 + [(Kr - 1) Rc]^2 / 2}
FIND Lp:
Lp = A / Lt
= [Pi^2 Kc {(2 (Rc + Rs)^2 + (Rs - Rc)^2) / 2}] / [Kc (Rs + Rc) Pi]
= Pi[(2 (Rc + Rs)^2 + (Rs - Rc)^2] / [2 (Rs + Rc)]
= Pi[((Rc + Rs) + (1 / 2) [(Rs - Rc)^2 / (Rs + Rc)]]
= Pi Rc [((Kr + 1) + (1 / 2) [(Kr - 1)^2 / (Kr + 1))]]
Note that Lp is independent of Kc.
Hence we can conclude that the initial assumption of:
[dZ / dR]^2 = {[(Kc^2 R^2) / (Rs - R) (R - Rc)] - 1}
is likely correct.
dZ / dR = +/-{[(Kc^2 R^2) / (Rs - R) (R - Rc)] - 1}^0.5O
Note that the sign of (dZ / dR) switches at:
R = Ro
Notes for plotting Z(R):
The object is to plot the function Z(R) for Rc < R < Rs
The real objective is to find [Ho / Rc] where Ho is the value of Z at R = Ro.
Hence we need to find:
Ho = Integral from R = Rc to R = Ro of:
[dZ / dR] dR
= Integral from R = Rc to R = Ro of:
+/- {[(Rs - Ro)(Ro - Rc)(R / Ro)^2 / (Rs - R) (R - Rc)] - 1}^0.5 dR
This expression needs numerical integration.
Note that Ro can take two different values so there may be two distinct solutions for [Ho / Rc].
Recall that:
Ro = Rc {(Kr + 1) +/- [(Kr - 1)^2 - (4 Kc^2 Kr)]^0.5 / 2 (1 + Kc^2)}
However, we only have Z(R) in closed form as a derivative (dZ / dR)
We need a numerical integration
We know that Z(Rc) = 0, and Z(Rs) = 0 and at R = Ro : (dZ / dR) = 0
Rc = inside diameter of spheromak at Z = 0;
Rs = Outside diameter of spheromak at Z = 0;
For Z > 0 and Rc < R < Ro use the positive value of (dZ / dR);
For Z > 0 and Ro < R < Rs use the negative value of (dZ / dR);
For Z < 0 and Rc < Ro use the negative value of (dZ / dR);
For Z < 0 and Ro , R < Rs use the positive value of (dZ / dR)
For R < 0 everything is a mirror reflection about the Z axis.
Please provide the output as a png file that is easy to post on the Internet.
Ho = Z|(R = Ro)
For initial plotting set Rc = 1.0, Rs = 4.2:
Ro = 2 Rs Rc / (Rs + Rc)
= 8.2 / 5.2 = 1.58
This is starting to look like a plasma spheromak.
This web page last updated May 11, 2026.
| Home | Energy Physics | Nuclear Power | Electricity | Climate Change | Lighting Control | Contacts | Links |
|---|